Blog Response #2 Part 1
For my
first part of this week’s blog I am looking at a brochure that was designed by
one of the realtors that I worked with at the real estate company. As I mentioned inn an earlier post, while
reading the chapters in white space is not your enemy I was bought back
to my days working as a receptionist. We
made hundreds on brochures, flyers and postcards and as I look back committed
quite a few sins. I have attached some pictures of the brochure, I tried to scan
it but my scanner refused.
Sin 1- Incessant blinking, does not apply to a brochure.
Sin 2-Warped Photos- Well there are not warped photos, but
in an attempt to get a great shot of the front of the house, which they did,
they turned the front page of the brochure on its side. The whole rest goes up and down, this may not
be listed as one of our “sins” but it is not aesthetically pleasing to me, so
it should be.
Sin 3-Naked photos and Sin 4 Bulky Borders and Boxes- I
think these two sins go together for this particular piece. All the photos have borders, but they are
bulky for sure. Here is why I don’t
think these bulky borders are a sin; they appear to be picture frames so it
makes each photo look like a tiny picture you would see hanging in a
house.
Sin 5-Cheated Margins-no, all the margins fit, nothing has
been cheated to make things fit.
Sin 6- Centering Everything- This one is two fold, each
description is centered in its own little text box but the boxes themselves are
not overly centered. For the most part
this is ok but in one or two blurbs the centering makes for hard reading, it
just doesn’t flow.
10 ft ceilings
through-out 1st floor
Breathtaking
Brazilian
Cherry Hardwood
Floors
Decorative Crown
Molding
Actually when I look at it the sin is in the wordiness, if you
take out the breathtaking Brazilian, which to me sounds like a painful waxing
procedure, it works.
Sin 7- 4 Corners & Clutter-No sin committed here,
although there is tons on information and pictures they, “group items together
that belong together!” Golombisky and Hagen refer to this as the clumping
effect.
Sin 8 & Sin 9 Trapped Negative Space and Busy
Backgrounds- there is no negative space on this brochure, no white space either
for that matter. Practically every inch of the inside of this brochure is
covered by text or photos.
Sin 10- Tacky Type- On my example there is no Reversing, or
Stroking, they don’t use all caps but they do capitalize key words for emphasis
like Hardwood Floors in the middle of a line.
His is what I would consider a minor sin. They don’t underline things. The thing they do which falls into this
category in my mind is they use very ornate handwriting font. In order to give the brochure and in turn the
house the feel of being expensive. I
find this type of font hard to read.
Sin 11- Bad Bullets- this example contains no bullets, but
when I made brochures or flyers while working for this company I was crazy
about aligning the bullets and the text.
Now that I
have picked this flyer to bits time to start creating my own to improve
on!


Hi Stacy,
ReplyDeleteI think you did a great job articulating the sins that were committed in the creation of this brochure layout. As I've commented in some of your colleagues' blogs previously, it's always great to see when students use materials that they've created in the past, to REALLY see how "easy" it is to commit these sins without even realizing it when in the moment of development.
I also appreciate hearing your voice within your blog posts -- your "Breathtaking Brazilian" comment made me laugh out loud.
I IMMEDIATELY noticed how difficult the font was to read within this brochure. Your comment about it looking expensive explains the reasoning for the use of such a font, but you're absolutely correct -- it does the company a disservice to advertise using such a font -- it's a turnoff for the reader if they have trouble getting through the document that lists its services!
Though you weren't able to scan your document, the quick thinking with taking a picture via your smartphone worked just fine.
Nice job!
Best,
Erica